Are health foods/supplements a con?
cheshirecat asked:
I just cannot believe the amount of vitamins/minerals/supplements that health food stores and online shops are selling to resolve all kinds of deficiencies which we are apparently all susceptible to. I appreciate there may be some benefit gained from them but we managed without them in the past why do we need them now? Does anyone here take them regularly and can you actually notice their effects? Or is it just scaremongering for money?
This entry was posted
on Monday, May 11th, 2009 at 7:43 pm and is filed under Diet & Fitness.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
I just cannot believe the amount of vitamins/minerals/supplements that health food stores and online shops are selling to resolve all kinds of deficiencies which we are apparently all susceptible to. I appreciate there may be some benefit gained from them but we managed without them in the past why do we need them now? Does anyone here take them regularly and can you actually notice their effects? Or is it just scaremongering for money?
May 14th, 2009 at 2:07 pm
i dunno i just came in here to look at ur pic. got an email? lets hook up some time woo woooo
May 15th, 2009 at 2:20 pm
Actually very recently the media has been releasing news that multivitamin pills are, in actuality, ineffective.
But I don’t think it’s right to say the same about all health foods such as fruits and whole wheat products. Those products are more natural and in the past people didn’t process their food due to lack of technology, so they avoided many of the deficiencies that we are susceptible to.
Also it is common knowledge that certain vitamins and minerals are actually necessary to your well-being. Lack of them poses a real threat to your health. Take, for example, osteoporosis brought upon by lack of calcium, or scurvy, brought upon by lack of vitamin C, and salts are essential for brain activity. It’s just that vitamin pills don’t cut it.
May 15th, 2009 at 11:43 pm
I use to take them regularly but I did not however notice much difference so I stopped buying them. I Think weight loss pills & rubbish like that is all a con.. & to be desperate enough to even buy that is sad. I do think however are body can only do so much so the use of vitamins & supplements is necessary in many cases for recovery or maybe where not getting enough protein in our meals?
I do still however drink protein shakes in the morning as breakfast is a meal I regularly miss, so its definitely worth having instead of nothing.
I hoped I helped in a small way
~Unknown Soldier~
May 17th, 2009 at 5:38 am
YES.
Unless your doctor recommends you take a certain product you are wasting your money to little effect.
My neighbour spent a small fortune on Q10 as she had problems with her gums. Her dentist said it made no difference and his hygienist did the job for a fraction of the money spent on Q10.
May 19th, 2009 at 3:24 am
Yes! Vitamins are the biggest con out there and what some people forget is that it’s a Multi million pound industry. Dr Frank and I always stick to science and fact; recent studies have shown that providing you are eating your ‘ 5 a day’ fruit and veg, taking vitamins supplements on top of this is of no therapeutic value. Studies show that those who do actually have a higher mortality rate.
I once fell victim to it all, at one point my kitchen cupboards looked like a Holland and Barret outlet. I also used to buy Berroca etc. I spent a fortune on these supplements until it suddenly occurred to me that they were not making any difference! The more I study the more I feel the need to trust only things that are supported by scientific evidence.
Diet pills are by far the worse con out there. All of them claim to help people lose x amount of weight and in small print it says ‘for best results combine with a healthy reduced calorie diet + exercise’. People are spending thousands on Hoodia, Alli and the pink patch etc and still they can’t see that if any of it actually worked, no one would ever be overweight!
May 20th, 2009 at 1:30 pm
I am afraid the overwhelming balance of evidence suggests that there are few if any health gains from the health food/supplement/vitamin industry.
Recent studies on vitamin supplements fail to show any fall in cancers or increase in life span for example.
I have always understood shops like Holland and Barrett selling things however ineffective they are, to people who want them, and we can all be tempted by promises of better health, skin, weight loss and virility, even Rhianna and myself, with above average IQs, are not immune.
However I do object violently to pharmacies selling such drivel, when they pretend in other areas to give evidence based advice.
May 22nd, 2009 at 12:08 am
Yes. Is the same as insurance scams. You pay out the a** for something you fear that may never happen. Is a billion dollar industry that is worthless to all but the companies selling it.
May 24th, 2009 at 10:47 pm
Well,
It depends on how you look at it; some vitamin supplements are essential for healthy living.
Supplements claiming to contain massive levels of a particular vitamin and claiming to be high strength is utterly useless because if the vitamins are water soluble the body will use them as it needs and excrete the ‘extra’ so you’re no better off, and the fat soluble ones actually build up in your body and can lead to toxicity symptoms; vitamin A being a case in point.
Supplements geared directly towards body builders help by increasing the protein intake to a level which would be unrealistic with food but then of course there is the issue of how much the body can use and so the rest is up to the individuals in question.
Iron and Calcium supplements are useful for women during pregnancy and women in general because they routienely lose these through menstruation and other processes.
Vitamin D, although it is naturally synthesized in the skin by contact with sunlight was not classed as a vitamin until quite recently, because vitamins are defined generally as essential nutrients the body is not capable of producing on it’s own - since the industrial revolution, with more people working indoors and wearing more layers of clothes, contact with sunlight has been reduced and Vitamin D related defficiency diseases became very prevalent, it was found that by artificial supplementation these could be reversed and so vitamin D was called a ‘vitamin’ and added to the growing list of vitals.
It’s important to be well-informed and responsible, realistic and remember that if something sounds too good to be true, it usually is.
Though I have to agree, there is a load of crap out there.